Home
Reviews
Readings
About the Author
Q&A
Other Books
Contact

Editorial reviews (Readers' reviews)

Kirkus Reviews
A lively blend of art history and travelogue covering the legacy of Carrara marble, the author's Italian roots and one of the greatest artists who ever lived.

The Italian town of Carrara, where Scigliano has family ties, has become synonymous with marble. It's a place that doesn't figure in the guidebooks: Carrara is an industrial place, "raw, rough-edged, and quirky . . . whose residents do something other than cater to tourists." Situated at the foot of the Apuan Alps, a giant block of fissured marble, it was once the center of the world's stone trade, though other countries--Brazil, India and, overwhelmingly, China--have since overtaken Italy. ("Italy is finished," an Indian matter-of-factly tells Scigliano.) Indeed, it is cheaper now for an Italian to purchase a piece of white Carraran marble, ship it to China to have it carved into a gravestone and place it in an Italian cemetery than it is to have the work done domestically, a condition that has driven the economy of Carrara, in the otherwise wealthy province of Tuscany, into the ground. The author connects the story of Carrara marble to Michelangelo, who favored it as a material: Just as there is an overpowering, elemental quality to the work of Michelangelo, exemplified in the magnificent David he carved from a block of unwanted Carraran stone, so there is an indomitable quality to the Carrarans, who have long been characterized by obdurate resistance to whatever powers happen to be. Fittingly, Michelangelo himself, as is well-documented, wasn't so easy to get along with. The Carraran quality of independence endures, but other differences are disappearing as new influences swamp the town: Many stoneworkers, one tells Scigliano, are devotees of yoga, and the clipped local dialect is increasingly the speech of the old as standard Italian enters via television.

An affectionate, gracefully written portrait of a little-known place that has suffered much pain to bring the world great beauty. (July 15, 2005)
 
Publishers Weekly
LIKE LEVI STRAUSS AND DENIM, Michelangelo and the Carrara quarries go together. As early as 1497, the Italian sculptor traveled there to acquire blocks of stunning white marble, thought to be the purest in the world, and over the next two decades he made several more trips, staying for as long as eight months at a time. From this marble, Michelangelo wrought the Pietá, David, Moses and the statuary of Pope Julius II's tomb. Scigliano's book is a sort of retrace-the-footsteps-of-Michelangelo journey through the Carrara quarries, present and past. Sprawling and garrulous, the book covers every little detail of both Michelangelo's history with the marble and Scigliano's own connection to it (his great-great-grandfather was a Carrara quarryman). Scigliano squeezes in presentations of marble arcana, conversations with today's cavatori, readings of Michelangelo's poems, mini-lessons in geology and language, accounts of the Sistine Chapel cleaning and the Vermont granite workers' strikes, and analysis of the impact of WWII on Tuscany—but his narrative isn't strong enough to hold the mix together convincingly. Clearly a labor of love, and perhaps of filial piety as well, the volume is exhaustive —an upward climb for the reader.

Readers' reviews
 
Jonathan Raban, author of Bad Land and Passage to Juneau
THIS IS A TERRIFIC BOOK, original in conception and exhilarating in its range and sweep. Eric Scigliano effortlessly marries the vibrant and tumultuous world of quattrocento and cinquecento Tuscan politics, philosophy, and art to his own 21st century travels in the region. Whether sketching a landscape, exploring the geology of marble, following Michelangelo from commission to commission, waxing lyrical on the curing of pork fat, or talking stonemasonry to elderly quarrymen in a Carrara bar, Scigliano is a deft, eloquent writer; the connections he makes are always surprising and often revelatory. His Michelangelo emerges as a man as much of our time and place as of his own.
 
William E. Wallace, author of Michelangelo: The Complete Sculpture, Painting, and Architecture
FROM THE MEDICI TO HENRY MOORE, from Rome to the Renaissance, to the modern quarry workers of Carrara, Eric Scigliano weaves a compelling narrative of marble, its mountains, and its greatest master and apprentice, Michelangelo Buonarroti
 
Paul Robert Walker, author of The Feud That Sparked the Renaissance
THIS IS A MASTERFUL WORK, in many respects a new kind of narrative nonfiction. Dancing seamlessly between past and present, Eric Scigliano illuminates Michelangelo through the sculptor's passion for special stone, set against the story of the stone itself and the people who still share that passion today. His strong, polished, yet informal prose—reminiscent at times of the marble he describes—is the perfect vehicle for this remarkable balancing act, while his personal connection with Cararra and easy familiarity with Italian documents bring a more palpable focus to the towering genius of the High Renaissance.
 
Robin Brooks, author of The Portland Vase
ERIC SCIGLIANO'S BOOK ON MICHELANGELO is vivid, erudite, and highly readable--a fresh take brilliantly executed.
 
David Tripp, author of Illegal Tender
JUST AS MICHELANGELO WRESTED WORKS OF GENIUS from the grip of the stone that possessed him, Eric Scigliano, with a Cararrese quarryman's blood running through his veins, has chipped away at the remarkable history of man's two thousand year obsession with the white mountain. His easy, almost conversational tone belies the comprehensively researched chronicle he narrates with erudition and wit.
 
Bruce Barcott, author of The Measure of a Mountain
ERIC SCIGLIANO WORKS MAGIC—in Michelangelo's Mountain he brings cold stone to brilliant, captivating life. With the tenacity of an investigative reporter, the deep knowledge of a cultural historian, and the infectious attitude of a bon vivant traveler, Scigliano prowls the Italian countryside uncovering the mystery of the marble that inspired Michelangelo's greatest masterpieces. You must listen to the stone, the master marble cutters of Carrara say, and in Scigliano's hands the stone yields an enchanting tale. Bravo!

© 2005 Eric Scigliano